Gun Control Activists Lobby for No ‘Untraceable Guns’ in Hearing on ATF’s 1.4 Billion Gun Records

Get the News2A App

Faster, cleaner, and instant alerts the moment major Second Amendment news breaks. Download free:

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
A government warehouse full of boxes of records

WASHINGTON — “The government needs to know about all your guns” is the most honest characterization of arguments put forth by gun control proponents during the November 18, 2026, House Oversight Committee’s hearing to discuss the more than 1.4 billion firearm-related records currently in the possession of the ATF. The hearing affirmed the long-suspected but rarely articulated desire of gun control advocates to ensure there are no “untraceable guns,” or in other words, a full and searchable registry.

The hearing, held by the Subcommittee on Federal Law Enforcement, entitled “Oversight of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives’ Out-of-Business Records Retention Practices,” was led by Rep. Clay Higgins (R-La.) and ranking member Rep. Greg Casar (D-Texas). The hearing was livestreamed on YouTube.

Four expert witnesses provided testimony:

  • Walfred A. Nelson, ATF Deputy Director (Retired) and Compliance Consultant
  • Aidan Johnston, Director of Federal Affairs, Gun Owners of America
  • Christopher Chiafullo, Founder and National Coordinating Counsel, FFLGuard (a law firm specializing in representing FFLs)
  • Gregory Jackson (Minority Witness), Former Deputy Director of the White House Office of Gun Violence Prevention

At the heart of the testimony were the 1.4 billion pages/images of out-of-business (OOB) FFL records (the majority of which have been digitized) held at the ATF’s National Tracing Center and how long these records should be maintained, if at all. According to Nelson, “Right now, ATF is getting 8 million records a month.”

Notably absent was ATF Director Robert Cekada, whose testimony established the 1.4 billion number, and whose agency actually oversees the disposition of these records.

The hearing pitted gun control advocates who sought to maintain the de facto and searchable registry and lengthy record retention times against gun rights advocates who noted that the current centralized record stockpile is in violation of federal law.

The discussion also addressed an ATF proposed rule introduced on May 6, which would require that records be retained for a specific period (either 20 or 30 years) rather than indefinitely.

“Technically, gun stores are required to send their records to ATF upon business discontinuance, but that’s it! Congress banned record centralization in 1978, so ATF directed OOB records to regional offices. It was in 1986 that ATF opened the ‘Out of Business Record Center,'” noted Aidan Johnston in an X post on the history of rules regarding records.

“Right now, in a records center in Martinsburg, West Virginia, the ATF holds more than 1.4 billion records that identify which Americans own which guns. Those records are searchable, and they can be weaponized against law-abiding gun owners for mass gun confiscation. … History is clear. Gun registration always leads to gun confiscation. … Unless ATF’s billion-record registry is dismantled and destroyed in full, it will remain a threat to the Second Amendment,” Johnston testified, on behalf of Gun Owners of America.

“The authority for ATF to receive the surrendered records does not by itself resolve every question about what happens next. … These records really maybe never should have been digitized to begin with pursuant to the law,” observed Chiafullo, representing the perspective of FFLs as “the original record keepers.”

Chiafullo also stated, “The authority for the ATF to receive these records does not by itself resolve everything ATF is allowed to do with these records.”

There was almost no challenge to the factuality of the statement regarding the centralization or searchability of the records from any of the Democratic representatives or Gregory Jackson, the minority witness. Jackson even deflected on the purpose of the hearing, stating, “This hearing is not about protecting the rights of Americans.”

Rather, the arguments supporting the maintenance of the registry largely ignored the legality of the measure and focused on the argument to support law enforcement.

“The out-of-business records are a crucial tool for tracing crime guns,” said Jackson, who went on to introduce a new victim class, claiming that gun violence is a “leading cause of newly disabled Americans.”

Jackson, along with Rep. Bell, a former prosecutor, employed dramatic appeals to emotion, attempting to draw a causal link between those who have been victims of violent crime and a need to retain gun records for decades.

However, as it relates to the left’s desire to maintain a registry, the most clarifying testimony came from Jackson:

“What is also dangerous about this is that it creates the evolution of untraceable guns. We know that in the murder of Charlie Kirk, the shooter intentionally got a gun that was older because he thought it would be harder to trace, and so we could potentially create a new evolution of untraceable firearms.”

Untraceable firearms cannot, of course, be put into a national registry, later to be confiscated or subject to mandatory “buy back” programs, as is happening in Australia. See our editorial on why President Trump ought to call for the destruction of the ATF’s illegal registry.

Get the News2A App

Faster, cleaner, and instant alerts the moment major Second Amendment news breaks. Download free:

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

While completely optional, we ask that you consider contributing to News2A’s independent, pro-Second Amendment journalism. If you feel we provide a valuable service, please consider participating in a value-for-value trade by clicking the button below. Whether you’d like to contribute on a one-time basis or a monthly basis, we graciously appreciate your support, no matter how big or how small. And if you choose not to contribute, you will continue to have full access to all content. Thank you!

Share this story

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted

They make it possible for us to bring you this content for free!